Mohave tui Chub: The Last Native Fish of the Mojave River

Mohave tui ChubPhoto – Joe Ferreia, California Fish & Wildlife

The Mohave tui chub (Siphateles bicolor mohavensis), formerly Gila bicolor mohavensis, is the only fish native to California’s Mojave River. It once lived throughout the river–inhabiting deep pools, sloughs, marshes, and backwaters from the Forks of the Mojave near the San Bernardino Mountains to Soda Lake near Baker. Now, it survives only in a few isolated refuges, making it one of the rarest native fishes in the American Southwest.

The Mojave River is unlike most North American rivers. It courses about 100 miles from the San Bernardino Mountains into the Mojave Desert, with most of its water underground. Surface flows occur only where bedrock forces groundwater to the surface, or when storms cause runoff. Despite being intermittent, the river once supported a rich aquatic ecosystem, including the Mohave tui chub.

The fish is a chunky, large-scaled minnow with a small terminal mouth, olive-brown to brassy back, and silver-white belly. Adults are usually 4 to 6 inches long; some reach 9 inches. Mohave tui chub feed on insect larvae, algae, and organic debris. Spawning runs from February to October, when females deposit thousands of adhesive eggs on aquatic plants.

For thousands of years, the species did well in the Mojave River basin. Its decline began in the early twentieth century as dams, groundwater pumping, and water diversions altered the river’s flow. Yet, habitat modification alone did not cause its disappearance.

Arroyo chub (Gila orcutti) – Hank Baker

Around 1930, arroyo chub (Gila orcutti), native to coastal Southern California streams, were introduced into reservoirs in the San Bernardino Mountains. Likely released by trout anglers or accidentally during fish stocking, they spread throughout the Mojave River after major floods in March 1938.

Unlike many introduced species that compete with native wildlife, the arroyo chub threatened the Mohave tui chub by interbreeding with it. Studies by Carl Hubbs and Robert Miller documented extensive hybridization and backcrossing. Over time, the native fish was absorbed into the introduced population. By the 1960s, pure Mohave tui chubs had disappeared from the Mojave River, and by 1970, the species was effectively extirpated from its native habitat.

Lake Tuendae

Fortunately, a small population survived in isolated ponds at Soda Springs near the lower end of the watershed. These fish formed the foundation for all subsequent recovery efforts.

Authorities immediately recognized the species’ precarious status. The Mohave tui chub was listed as endangered under federal law in 1970, and the State of California followed in 1971. California also designated it as a Fully Protected species. In 1984, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service completed a recovery plan to prevent extinction and to establish secure refuge populations.

Today, genetically pure Mohave tui chubs survive in only a few places: Lake Tuendae at Zzyzx, Camp Cady Wildlife Area, MC Spring, and the Lark Seep system at China Lake. The China Lake population is regarded as the most secure. Since the mid-1990s, annual surveys there have estimated the number of fish in thousands. Water quality monitoring, invasive species control, habitat management, and vegetation removal help maintain suitable conditions.

Modern genetic studies have greatly improved the understanding of the species. Yongjiu Chen, Steve Parmenter, and Bernie May used microsatellite DNA analysis to examine surviving populations and compare them with fish from the Mojave River. Their results confirmed that refuge populations remain genetically pure Mohave tui chubs, while fish occupying the Mojave River today are pure arroyo chubs.

Mohave tui Chub – Arroyo Chub – photo Walter Feller

The study revealed key differences among populations. Lake Tuendae and China Lake have high genetic diversity and are genetically similar. Camp Cady has lower diversity because it was founded by only 10 fish. MC Spring shows the lowest diversity, likely due to long isolation and genetic change. The researchers recommended boosting gene flow among populations and creating new ones from the most diverse sites.

While the Mohave tui chub survived, the Mojave River itself continued to change. By 2002, at least twenty-two non-native fish species had entered the watershed. Introduced species dominated fish communities in the middle and lower Mojave River. Researchers documented six exotic species in their study reaches and found evidence of continued hybridization among non-native fishes. In some locations, other introduced species displaced even the arroyo chub.

Many scientists concluded restoration of Mohave tui chub to its historic range would be very difficult. The river’s ecology has been fundamentally changed by invasive species, water development, habitat modification, and altered hydrology. While some reintroductions might be possible within controlled settings, restoring the species throughout the Mojave River now appears unlikely.

Despite these challenges, important habitat remains. One example is the Transition Zone of the Mojave River, where perennial surface water supports a fifteen-mile corridor of cottonwood and willow forest. Conservation measures have protected portions of this habitat, including the 1,647-acre Palisades Ranch. The property contains approximately 3.5 miles of Mojave River frontage and hundreds of acres of riparian forest, supporting a remarkable diversity of wildlife.

Species benefiting from the protection of the river corridor include the southwestern willow flycatcher, least Bell’s vireo, western yellow-billed cuckoo, Mojave River vole, southwestern pond turtle, arroyo toad, desert tortoise, Mohave ground squirrel, burrowing owl, and Mohave shoulderband snail. The area also contains habitat that could support Mohave tui chub if biological and hydrological obstacles are overcome.

The story of the Mohave tui chub is both a conservation success and a cautionary narrative. The species disappeared from the river where it evolved, not primarily because of direct predation or habitat destruction, but because it was replaced by genetic introgression from an introduced relative. Yet biologists, land managers, and conservation agencies worked together to save the fish from extinction.

Now, the Mohave tui chub is a living remnant of the earliest Mojave River ecosystem. Its survival depends on protected refuges, careful genetic management, and protection of remaining river stretches. As the only fish native to the Mojave River basin, it is a key symbol of the desert’s natural heritage.

Mohave tui Chub

Sensitive Fish Species

Lake Tuendae

Mojave River

Curtis Howe Springer and the Complicated Story of Zzyzx

Curtis Howe Springer and the Complicated Story of Zzyzx

Curtis Howe Springer was a radio preacher, health-product salesman, resort promoter, and one of the Mojave Desert’s most unusual characters. He was neither simply a generous desert visionary nor merely a confidence man. He built a functioning community, provided work and shelter, attracted visitors, and helped Baker’s economy. He also used credentials he had not earned, advertised products with unsupported medical claims, and operated a large resort on federal land he did not own.

Springer arrived at Soda Springs in 1944 with Helen Springer. He filed mining claims covering about 12,800 acres and renamed the place Zzyzx, which he promoted as “the last word in health.” From a collection of tents and old ruins, the Springers developed a resort with guest rooms, a dining hall, a chapel, mineral baths, a swimming pool, radio facilities, workshops, gardens, animal pens, and an airstrip.

Much of this was real. Zzyzx wasn’t simply a name on a brochure. People lived, worked, ate, worshiped, and vacationed there for nearly 30 years. The federal court later described four guest buildings containing 59 units, a dining room and kitchen, an administration building, a chapel, mineral baths, electrical equipment, and numerous other structures.

Work and Economic Benefits

Springer’s operation created work at Zzyzx and generated business in nearby Baker. Workers mixed and packaged health foods, printed literature, prepared radio recordings, filled orders, handled correspondence, maintained buildings, cooked meals, cared for animals, and mailed products.

Some workers were recruited from Los Angeles’ Skid Row. They were offered food, shelter, a small wage, and a place away from alcohol in exchange for construction and maintenance work. This labor helped Springer build the resort at relatively low cost, but it also provided men with few alternatives, a temporary home, and useful work.

Zzyzx also affected Baker. Visitors sometimes stayed in Baker motels while waiting to enter the resort. Springer’s enormous volume of packages, promotional literature, donations, and correspondence helped raise the Baker post office to first-class status. The federal court record specifically confirms that foods, printed materials, and radio recordings were packaged and prepared for mailing at Zzyzx.

However, Springer did not cause Baker’s first post office to be established. Postal records show that the office began under the name Silver Lake on March 27, 1907. It was renamed Baker in February 1933, eleven years before Springer arrived. His business greatly increased its workload, but it did not create the first post office.

Was Springer Rich?

Springer appears to have become wealthy during Zzyzx’s most successful years. The National Park Service describes him as a millionaire. His radio broadcasts reached hundreds of stations, while listeners sent donations and ordered teas, food supplements, books, and other products. The National Park Service states that he shipped more than four million packages during his years at Zzyzx.

One witness later recalled that Springer paid a $2,500 court fine immediately, treating it like a minor expense. This suggests that he had considerable available money.

His exact personal wealth is still unknown. No dependable financial statement or estate accounting has been found. Some of his apparent wealth was represented by buildings and improvements at Zzyzx. Those improvements stood on federal land, and Springer never obtained legal title to the property. He could control the operation while he occupied it, but he did not own a desert estate that he could legally sell.

The Ownership Problem

Springer held unpatented mining claims. Such claims allowed legitimate mineral exploration and mining, along with activities reasonably connected to mining. They did not automatically transfer ownership of the land.

The United States remained the legal owner. Springer’s hotel, health resort, food-packaging operation, radio studio, pools, airstrip, residential buildings, and religious activities went far beyond ordinary mining.

Springer made several attempts to obtain a stronger legal right to the property. He filed desert-land applications in 1951, public-recreation applications in 1957 and 1958, and another non-mineral application in 1966. These applications were rejected, dismissed, or denied. Despite those decisions, he continued operating Zzyzx.

In 1970, a federal district court restricted the property to mining-related uses. A 1971 injunction prohibited Springer from operating the resort, renting rooms, packaging food, preparing mail, recording broadcasts, maintaining pools, or inviting people to live there for purposes unrelated to mining. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that injunction.

The legal record, therefore, leaves little doubt about ownership: Springer and his organizations built and operated Zzyzx, but the United States owned the land.

Was Springer Selling Land?

There is evidence that Springer marked off residential lots and allowed major donors to build homes on them. Some historical accounts describe this as offering or selling parcels to supporters.

The wording requires care. Springer could promise someone a place to live or accept a donation in exchange for the use of a lot, but he could not convey valid ownership because he did not own the land. No deed from Springer could transfer federal property.

It is therefore safest to say that Springer allocated or offered homesites to donors as if he controlled the property. Whether every arrangement was described as a direct sale is less certain. What is certain is that donors could not receive a valid title from him.

Would Nonprofit Status Have Helped?

Nonprofit status would not have solved Springer’s central problems. In fact, organizations connected with Zzyzx already included the Dr. Curtis Howe Springer Foundation and the Zzyzx Community Church. Both were named in the federal land case.

A properly managed nonprofit could have accepted donations, operated a retreat, and possibly applied for an authorized lease or public-purpose agreement. It still would have needed federal approval to occupy the land. It would also have been required to follow food, drug, advertising, tax, and charitable organization laws.

Calling the resort a church, foundation, charity, or nonprofit could not transform a mining claim into ownership. It also could not legalize false medical advertising or the unauthorized distribution of public land.

A nonprofit might have helped only if Springer had reorganized the operation, stopped making unsupported health claims, kept proper financial records, and obtained a valid federal lease. The government had already rejected several of his applications, so nonprofit status alone would not have guaranteed that result.

Why Springer Went to Prison

Springer was not imprisoned merely for being eccentric, practicing natural health, or building a resort in the desert. The strongest court evidence concerns false advertising and misbranded foods.

The Ninth Circuit record states that he had been convicted on 18 counts of false advertising involving supposed remedies for hemorrhoids, heart disease, nervous conditions, thyroid problems, and goiter. It also records violations of California food-misbranding laws.

Springer was fined and sentenced to 60 days in jail. After appeals, he reportedly served 49 days. His imprisonment should be distinguished from the land dispute. The land case was primarily a federal civil action for an injunction, damages, ejectment, and eviction. His false advertising and food law convictions provided the criminal penalties.

Thus, two legal problems came together:

  1. Springer used federal mining-claim land for a resort, residence, manufacturing, and mail-order business.
  2. He advertised health products with claims that authorities and courts found false or misleading.

The first problem cost him Zzyzx. The second resulted in penalties and imprisonment.

Did the Rehabilitation Program Work?

Some men probably benefited from their time at Zzyzx, although their progress was never formally documented. Springer offered homeless and struggling men food, shelter, work, routine, and an alcohol-free environment. The National Park Service has concluded that these conditions certainly helped some visitors.

Springer later claimed that Zzyzx had helped rehabilitate 4,000 destitute men. That figure came from Springer himself. No known records follow these men after they left, nor do they show how many remained sober, found permanent employment, reunited with families, or established stable homes.

Zzyzx was not a licensed rehabilitation center with trained counselors, medical supervision, case records, or long-term follow-up. Nevertheless, temporary shelter and meaningful work can still help people. The fair conclusion is that Springer probably helped some individuals, but his claim of 4,000 successful rehabilitations cannot be verified.

Eviction and Final Years

After years of court proceedings, federal authorities removed Springer and his followers from Zzyzx in 1974. The government did not recognize his ownership claims, and Springer could not take the property with him or sell it as his estate.

In 1976, the Bureau of Land Management permitted the California State University system to use the site. Zzyzx became the Desert Studies Center, where students and researchers continue to study Mojave Desert biology, geology, hydrology, and history.

Springer and Helen moved to Las Vegas after the eviction and his short imprisonment. He remained there for the rest of his life. Curtis Howe Springer died in Las Vegas on August 19, 1985, at age 88. Available sources do not identify the particular residence or hospital where he died.

A Balanced Judgment

Springer’s story resists a simple conclusion. He was a persuasive promoter who made unsupported medical claims and used public land far beyond the limits of his mining claims. He accepted money and donations while presenting himself as a doctor and minister, even though he lacked recognized qualifications. His legal troubles were based on substantial evidence, not simply disagreement with unconventional medicine.

At the same time, he built a real desert community. Zzyzx provided jobs, meals, shelter, inexpensive vacations, religious fellowship, and temporary stability. His mail-order business supported packaging and mailing work and brought measurable business to Baker. Some people remembered him with sincere thanks.

His good works did not give him ownership of federal land, and nonprofit status would not have erased the legal violations. Likewise, his unlawful conduct does not mean that nobody benefited from Zzyzx. Both parts belong in history.

Sources

United States v. Springer, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

Mojave National Preserve Administrative History

National Park Service: Zzyzx

Los Angeles Times: Zzyzx and Curtis Howe Springer

California Post Office Records

SFGATE: The History of Zzyzx Road

Zzyzx